Monday, December 18, 2023

And the one Christmas special that represents the true meaning of Christmas is…..

 

It is the time of year for tons of yuletide traditions: Sending Christmas cards to our friends and family far away-that has been happening since 1843.  The decorating of the Christmas tree-we have been doing since sometime around the 16th century.  The singing Christmas carols (1st one “Jesus Illuminates All”, 336 A.D), and kicking back and watching a bunch of Christmas specials/movies.

Over the Thanksgiving holiday I had an interesting discussion of what constitutes a Christmas movie or special.   For example, some would argue that the movie “Die Hard” is a Christmas movie.  It does, after all, take place on Christmas Eve with John McClane coming to L.A. to see his kids and perhaps fix the relationship with his soon-to-be ex-wife Holly.  It begins with the limo driver playing Run DMC “Christmas in Hollis” while taking John to his wife’s office where they are having a huge Christmas party.   The film, however, quickly devolves from that point into a stereotypical action movie that was popular in the 1980’s with Bruce Willis trying to give Sylvester Stallone and Arnold Schwarzenegger a run for their box office money.   Is it a good movie?  Yes, it is a good action movie. But it isn’t the 1st movie that comes to mind when I think of a Christmas movie.

“Die Hard” I would dub as a Fil -in -the -Blank genre movie that has a Christmas label stuck on it. If you want to call “Die Hard” a Christmas movie you can but it has very little to do with Christmas and certainly doesn’t reflect the true meaning of Christmas.   The movie “Gremlins” could also be called a Christmas movie. In reality, though, “Gremlins” is a PG-13 horror film with those little green monsters terrorizing the town of Kingston Falls at Christmas.  I would also classify most of the Hallmark Channel’s lineups under this category as well with them rehashing the same romantic comedy tropes against a Christmas backdrop.   Heck I would even throw such notable classic Christmas movies as the Bing Crosby Rosemary Clooney musical “White Christmas” in the Fill in the blank genre movie with Christmas label stuck to it category because it’s more of a musical spectacular than it is about the Christmas holiday.

Then there are the movies and specials that clearly are about Christmas because they feature the ultimate icon of Christmas-Santa Claus. Now Santa doesn’t have to be even the main character or have the movie or special revolve entirely around Santa for it to qualify as a Santa film.   The movie “Elf” is about an orphaned baby boy named Buddy who was raised by elves trying to find his human birth parents and Santa is only tangentially connected to it.   The most famous Rankin Bass stop motion Christmas special was all about Santa suddenly needing reindeer with a built-in spotlight hence Rudolph’s becoming an insider rather than an outsider of the Christmas world.   A Santa movie is a wonderful thing at Christmas because as famous editor of the New York Sun posted to young 8 year old Virginia when she asked if Santa was real  “(Santa) exists as certainly as love and generosity and devotion exist, and you know that they abound and give to your life its highest beauty and joy.” [i]   And I would say most Santa films embody that feeling of love and generosity that abound during the Christmas season.

But there are certainly other notable Christmas classics that aren’t just some other type of movie with a Christmas label attached to it or something that takes place within the greater Santa Claus cinematic multiverse.  Those I would say embody that spirit of Christmas but not quite the true meaning of Christmas. They capture that feeling of love, generosity and joy so much they become obvious Christmas classics.  The movie “It’s A Wonderful Life” is really a 140 minute pre-“The Twilight Zone” episode done in the Frank Capra heartfelt patriotic style.   But somehow “It’s a Wonderful Life” is more than some weird sci-fi mystical plot about an angel showing how the world is worse off without George Bailey in it.   Because it has that heart and spirit of generosity people love this film and it fits Christmas’ overall theme.  The 1966 Chuck Jones TV adaptation of his fellow cartoonist buddy’s Dr. Seuss book “How the Grinch Stole Christmas” could be classified as a Santa film with the Grinch being an anti-Claus who steals things rather than gives them.  In the end though, the Grinch realizes that Christmas isn’t material it’s spiritual and the joy he receives causes him to repent of his Grinchy ways so he too can spread the Christmas love.   Charles Dickens “A Christmas Carol” is by Dickens’ own words a ghost story. Yet, the theme that Scrooge must care more for humanity than his personal wealth is the epitome of that Christmas spirit of generosity and love and how if we recognize it we can change.   Then there is that brilliant “A Charlie Brown Christmas”.   The one thing that the networks hated about the Peanuts Christmas special was Linus getting up and reciting Luke 2:Vrs 1-14. Charles Schulz insisted that that biblical passage be in there because “That’s really what Christmas is all about Charlie Brown.”    And maybe why this particular secular special has been so beloved for almost 60 years is because this secular show does a good job recognizing the true meaning of Christmas.  I found a comment online pointing out when Linus is reciting the Gospel of Luke he drops his security blanket when he says “Fear not!”   As soon as the actual Gospel of Christmas is said out loud suddenly Charlie Brown is happier and the Peanuts gang, who have been very nasty to him through much of the special, go out of their way to be nice to him. 

So, does that mean that the only true Christmas specials are the ones who re-present or explore the world of the Nativity of Jesus?  There aren’t too many depictions of Jesus’ birth that makes it into our regular viewing habits for some reason.  Some are better than others.   For example, I prefer to watch the Rankin Bass “Little Drummer Boy” about how a boy filled with hate gets overcome by love as he plays a drum solo for baby Jesus to the other Rankin Bass Nativity themed special “Nestor: The Long -Eared Christmas Donkey” which was just a rehashing of the Rudolph plot with Nestor saving Mary, Joseph and Baby Jesus on their way to Bethlehem.   Dallas Jenkins’ “The Shepherd” was so good it lead to the #1 crowdfunded project of all time “The Chosen”.  I think what made it good is that it realistically depicted how frightening it would be if an army of angels suddenly appeared in the sky in addition to making a protagonist that was put upon and derided by everyone around him because he was a cripple. (Making his healing and being the 1st one to hold baby Jesus after Mary & Joseph all the sweeter).  Yet, these Nativity specials, while showing the reason for the season, don’t necessarily get to the heart of why the Son of God had to become incarnate in human flesh to begin with.    

So, allow me to explain the Christmas movie/special has more to do with the true meaning of Christmas than most TV specials.  It’s Pixar’s “The Toy Story that Time Forgot” which came out around Christmas 2014 and aired on Disney owned ABC. [ii]  The special itself is at first glance only nominally Christmas-y.   The story takes place about two days after Christmas which makes sense since the only times a year a kid gets a lot of new toys is either on their birthday or on Jesus’ birthday.   The plot features Bonnie packing up Buzz, Woody, Rex, Trixie, and a stuffed kitty angel ornament that’s been hanging on Bonnie’s tree for a playdate with her friend Mason at his house.  Now prior to Bonnie dragging her toys to her friend Mason’s home the show opens up with Trixie the plastic triceratops lamenting how Bonnie is never allowing her to be the big blue plastic dinosaur she is in the Pixar universe.   Once Bonnie arrives with backpack & toys in tow to Mason’s home Mason quickly urges Bonnie to play with him on his new videogame console in his game room.   Bonnie quickly throws her backpack into Mason’s playroom where the Toy Story toys quickly realize Santa was very good to Mason because Santa gave him a vast collection of these half human/half dinosaur action figures and matching playsets.  Trixie quickly befriends one of the half human/half dino action figures named Reptillus and they develop a borderline romance.  Of course, per Toy Story logic most action figures do not know they are toys and begin to act out their commercial alter egos for better towards Trixie and fellow plastic dino Rex, and for worse towards Buzz and Woody who find themselves in the center of a sci-fi dino dystopian colosseum fighting for their lives!   The humanoid dino creatures are at one point about to send Buzz, Woody, and the kitty angel ornament to their deaths down a heating vent shaft (with the kitty angel playing “O Come O Come Emanuel” on her decorative trumpet) when Trixie manages to make her way into the game room (unseen of course because also by Toy Story rules no toy can be seen as alive) to shut off the power to Mason’s game console, thereby forcing Mason & Bonnie to play with the physical toys and not the virtual ones.  Before she gets there her new Dino boyfriend Reptillus tries to stop her. Trixie then convinces Reptillus he is more than just some plastic warrior.  By accepting the fact he is a toy and surrendering to something/someone greater than himself he can go beyond what he had ever imagined.   I think Reptillus ultimately shuts the power off and allows himself to be held by Mason and let Mason determine his actions.   Afterwards Reptillius described the feeling of being a plaything in Mason’s hands, not knowing anything about the outcome or what he was supposed to be as a glorious experience.

Now, you ask, why did God send his only begotten Son to be our Lord and savior.  It’s because in some ways like Mason’s toys we too are trapped in a tiny ego world of our own making and we often make a mess of it.  Sometimes we too need to surrender to our higher power a.k.a. God and let him dictate our ways.  Because it we do, we too can experience something glorious.  And once we do, we too can then spread that glory of God’s love and devotion to the rest of the world.  



[i] Frank B. Church, Editor of the New York Sun, 1897

No comments:

Post a Comment